A coalition of traditional football clubs from Eastern Germany is advocating for a reconsideration of the penalties associated with the use of pyrotechnics in stadiums. In a recent statement, these clubs expressed that under certain conditions, the use of pyrotechnics should not incur penalties. This proposal has been shared by various clubs, including the second-division Hertha BSC, along with third-division teams such as Dynamo Dresden, FC Erzgebirge Aue, Hansa Rostock, and Energie Cottbus, as well as their respective fan organizations. Notably absent from the signatories were Bundesliga teams Union Berlin and 1. FC Magdeburg, although some fan groups participated. The clubs argue that the increasing financial penalties imposed for pyrotechnic use are creating significant economic burdens and diminishing their competitiveness. They contend that the evolving penalty framework has shifted perceptions, neglecting the positive contributions of pyrotechnics to the stadium atmosphere, as well as their negligible impact on match dynamics. The clubs highlighted that the associations have overlooked the heightened sense of safety associated with pyrotechnics, pointing out that there has been a lack of injuries related to their use. They assert that the rising penalties have not resulted in a decrease in pyrotechnic displays. This movement comes amid ongoing debates over safety and the role of fan expression in sports. Proponents of the use of pyrotechnics argue that when executed responsibly, these displays can enhance the ambience of live matches, showcasing fan passion and creativity. However, governing bodies have maintained strict regulations, often citing safety concerns and the potential for misuse. The clubs involved are urging football associations to reassess their stance on pyrotechnics, advocating for regulations that distinguish between responsible usage and reckless behavior. The push for regulatory change reflects a broader conversation within the sport about balancing safety with the vibrant culture that fans bring to matches. As the discussion unfolds, it remains to be seen how football governing bodies will respond to these calls for reform. The clubs are hopeful that their request will prompt a constructive dialogue about the future of pyrotechnics in football, aiming for a framework that recognizes both safety and the unique contributions of passionate fan communities.