Conservative Cardinals Eye Robert Sarah as Potential Successor to Pope Francis

Tue 22nd Apr, 2025

The passing of Pope Francis has prompted a wave of speculation regarding his successor, particularly among conservative factions within the Catholic Church. One name that has emerged prominently is Cardinal Robert Sarah from Guinea, who is viewed as a hardliner and a potential candidate to reverse many of Francis's reforms.

Pope Francis, the first pontiff from Latin America, was known for his progressive stance on issues such as social justice, environmental concerns, and inclusivity within the church. His tenure was marked by efforts to promote dialogue and openness, which some conservative Catholics now see as an opportunity to pivot back to traditional values.

Cardinal Sarah, who has openly criticized liberal theological perspectives, represents a stark contrast to Francis's approach. He is known for his rigid adherence to doctrine and a cultural conservatism that appeals to many right-leaning Catholics. His views resonate particularly in the United States, where some conservative Catholics hope that his elevation to the papacy could halt or reverse the reforms initiated by his predecessor.

Sarah has been vocal about his opposition to issues such as abortion, pornography, and gender equality initiatives, which he believes undermine the foundational principles of Western civilization. He has also expressed strong disapproval of the changing dynamics surrounding the Latin Mass and the blessing of same-sex unions, which he considers a deviation from traditional Catholic teachings.

In recent years, Sarah gained attention for his rejection of the Vatican's position on the blessing of same-sex unions, framing it not just as a disagreement but as a defense against what he terms heretical ideas that deviate from core church teachings. He argues that such ideologies are incompatible with the beliefs of faithful Christians and detrimental to the moral fabric of society.

Beyond his views on social issues, Sarah has also warned about the threats posed by radical ideologies, including Islamic fundamentalism, which he characterized as one of two significant 'apocalyptic monsters' facing the West. He has called for vigilance against what he perceives as a decline in moral values driven by secularism and materialism.

These positions have made Sarah a favored candidate among conservative Catholics, especially in the U.S., where there are calls for his appointment as the next pope. Influential voices within the conservative Catholic community have advocated for his selection, citing his commitment to tradition and liturgy as critical qualities for the next pontiff.

Despite the backing from some conservative circles, the likelihood of Sarah becoming the next pope remains uncertain. Current betting markets indicate that he is not among the frontrunners, with estimates of his chances being significantly lower than those of other prominent candidates like Cardinals Pietro Parolin and Luis Antonio Tagle.

As the Catholic Church navigates this transitional period, the selection of the next pope will undoubtedly have lasting implications for its direction and the global Catholic community. The evolving dynamics between progressive and conservative factions will continue to shape the discourse surrounding this pivotal moment in church history.


More Quick Read Articles »