Union and SPD Encounter Unexpected Setbacks in Judiciary Appointment

Fri 11th Jul, 2025

The final day before the summer recess has turned chaotic for Germany's political landscape as new allegations against Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf have emerged overnight. The anticipated votes for the appointment of new constitutional judges have been postponed, leading to uncertainty in the Bundestag.

On Friday morning, the start time of the Union faction's special session was delayed by several minutes. Originally scheduled for 8 a.m., it was held up as federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Jens Spahn, the leader of the Union faction, attempted to contact Lars Klingbeil, the head of the SPD. The discussion centered around Brosius-Gersdorf's candidacy for the position of judge at the Federal Constitutional Court.

Historically, this situation draws parallels to events from 2008 when the SPD attempted to nominate Brosius-Gersdorf's doctoral advisor, Horst Dreier, as a constitutional judge. That nomination faced significant backlash and ultimately did not materialize. Today, the political climate appears similarly fraught.

In the face of these developments, the CSU's faction leader, Hoffmann, has come to the defense of Brosius-Gersdorf, asserting that she is not a radical activist, despite differing views on legal priorities within her own party. This defense comes as the SPD continues to navigate the complexities surrounding her nomination.

The process for electing constitutional judges is governed by strict timelines set by the Bundestag. However, the Federal Constitutional Court itself operates with a degree of flexibility concerning timing. As a result, Brosius-Gersdorf's appointment is now in limbo, raising questions about how the situation will evolve in the coming weeks.

As political factions grapple with the implications of these new allegations, all eyes remain on the Union and SPD as they strive to reach a consensus on the judicial appointments that are crucial for the integrity of Germany's legal framework.


More Quick Read Articles »