Linus Torvalds to Override Maintainer Objections to Rust Kernel Code

Wed 19th Feb, 2025

Linus Torvalds, the founder of the Linux kernel, has indicated a willingness to proceed with the integration of Rust programming language support into the kernel, even if the maintainer of the specific subsystem opposes it. This position emerged from a private discussion between Torvalds and Christoph Hellwig, a prominent figure in the Linux community, who has expressed resistance to Rust-based Direct Memory Access (DMA) interfaces.

While Torvalds has not publicly announced his stance on this issue, Hellwig recently mentioned in a communication that Torvalds had privately confirmed he would merge Rust code despite any objections from subsystem maintainers. This approach mirrors corporate practices where leadership may intervene in disputes, suggesting a potential shift in how contributions to the Linux kernel are managed.

As of now, no formal action has been taken regarding the Rust DMA code, leaving the community anticipating whether Torvalds will directly accept the code following further review or if Hellwig will ultimately approve it himself.

Hellwig has also articulated his support for incorporating safer programming languages into the kernel, emphasizing the desire for improved security. However, he has raised concerns about the complexities that a multi-language codebase might introduce, sparking renewed discussions about the advantages and challenges of adopting Rust and other programming languages in enhancing kernel security.

This ongoing debate highlights the broader implications of integrating new programming languages into established codebases, particularly in the context of open-source projects like Linux, where collaboration and consensus among maintainers are crucial for the project's evolution.


More Quick Read Articles »