CSU Proposes New Candidates for Constitutional Court Amid Criticism

The Christian Social Union (CSU) is advocating for a fresh slate of candidates to fill three vacancies at the Federal Constitutional Court, suggesting that these new nominees could comprise entirely new individuals. This proposal was articulated by the head of the CSU parliamentary group, who indicated a willingness to reconsider the Union's current nominee, Günter Spinner, in light of the ongoing dispute. The CSU leader expressed a desire to resolve the impasse, stating that the summer period should be utilized to reach a consensus, promoting a calm approach to the situation. He mentioned the possibility of withdrawing all three candidates or just one or two, highlighting a flexible stance in negotiations. The proposal, however, has met with backlash from coalition partners SPD and the Greens. The leader of the Green parliamentary group criticized the CSU's suggestion as a peak of disrespect toward the already nominated individuals. She questioned the implications for future candidates if the CDU and CSU can so arbitrarily withdraw their support, emphasizing the potential damage to the German Bundestag's integrity. The Greens reaffirmed their support for all three existing candidates. The SPD also rejected the CSU's proposal, reiterating their commitment to their two nominated candidates. The Vice Chancellor and Federal Minister of Finance called for a reexamination of the nominations for the candidates who had previously been set for a vote. The nomination process for the three candidates was abruptly removed from the Bundestag's agenda on July 11 due to internal dissent within the Union faction regarding the SPD candidate, Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf. Following earlier assurances, the Union leadership was unable to confirm support for Brosius-Gersdorf, who has faced scrutiny within the Union for her liberal views on abortion. Furthermore, the Federal Minister of Justice has urged the Union faction to accept an invitation from Brosius-Gersdorf for dialogue, emphasizing the importance of open discussions. The Minister expressed confidence in the qualifications of all three candidates and stressed the need for a prompt resolution to the matter, which is crucial for all parties involved, including the Federal Constitutional Court.