How interfering with your vision can shatter your recall of the way things look

How do we recall our stored knowledge of the physical properties of objects? Do we "see" things all over again when asked simple questions about the way common and familiar things look? Do brain centers that process visual images fire up all over again when we think about the physical properties of things or is it a more abstract process?

"Yes" to the last two questions, according to Pierce Edmiston and Dr. Gary Lupyan of the Department of Psychology at the University of Wisconsin at Madison.

Edmiston believes that visual knowledge depends on visual mechanisms because "when people respond to questions about what things look like, the visual areas of their brain become active." This view of the brain in Edmiston and Lupyan's study challenges a view of the brain as a sort of archive, where information is stored in an abstract way and kept independent of perception.

Brain imagery and humpless dromedaries

In order to decide whether this activation of visual areas of people's brains is absolutely necessary for accessing what we know about how things look and not merely secondary to accessing that knowledge, Edmiston asked participants in his study to answer "yes" or "no" questions about common objects, "Is a table flat?", "Does a camel have a hump"; questions requiring the participant to summon their visual recall in response.

During some of the questions, participants sat in front of a computer screen filled with rectangles filled with flashing static; their visual processing "space", meaning the ability to use their visual knowledge, was disrupted.

Evidence of the disruption was both the increase in their reaction times in response to the questions and in their error rate when questioned about properties of common objects or the appearances of animals.

This visual interference from the staticky shapes caused study participants to make more mistakes when asked about the appearances of things than when they looked at empty, static-less shapes on the screen.

To show that this interference only played a role in visual recall, when participants were asked questions that called for more abstract, non-visual knowledge there was no difference in error rate or slowing of reaction time, when flashing static was presented compared to blank shapes.

Interfering with your vision hampers recall of images, shows that visual knowledge is specifically interfered with. A non-visual question relies on more abstract distinctions between things and involves categorizing them. And since staticky rectangles didn't wreak havoc on participants' responses requiring non-visual knowledge, this type of information may be stored in an abstract format.

We know what we see and see what we know

According to Edmiston, "These results challenge a view of the brain in which information is stored in an abstract and symbolic format, independent of bodily experiences."

In other words, our visual long-term memory of the physical qualities of objects seems to be indispensably and physically wedded to our sight.

"Long term memory for even familiar objects still utilizes the neural mechanisms involved in recreating specific bodily experiences, like seeing," remarks Edmiston.


Image credit: Designed by Asierromero -

Write a comment ...
Post comment

Tollwood 2016

Tollwood 2016
Artistics at its best with Cirque Eloize's "Saloon". The Tollwood Winter Festival takes place from 23rd of November to 31st of December at...

Munich OEZ Mall Attack

HOTLINE for concerned relatives or enquiries about missing people: 0800 7766350 UPDATE (01:30): police issue statement to clarify that only one...

Grafing S-Bahn Knife Attack

Grafing station, scene of knife attack
Shortly before 05:00 this morning at Grafing station, a knife-wielding assailant attacked a number of commuters, killing one man and injuring three...

Ten killed as trains collide in Bavaria

Bad Aibling train collision
Two trains collided head-on killing ten people and injuring more than 100 near Bad Aibling, about 60 kilometres southeast of Munich in Bavaria.


Karneval countdown

Fasching with Karneval Universe
As the temperature dips below freeezing and Munich beds down for the long-avoided winter, Fasching season arrives and promises to be even better...

New Data Proves German Soccer Fans Are Amongst The Most Patriotic In Europe

German fans proud of their colours
Germans have never been famous for their patriotism, perhaps only outdone by the English in their unwillingness to fly the national flag. Indeed, as...

Engineering Jobs Fair in Munich

Munich engineering recruitment fair
The Association of German Engineers (VDI) is hosting an engineering recruitment fair on the 17th November in Munich. The day-long event commences at...

Axe attack on Wurzburg Train

Axe attack in Wurzburg
Four people have been injured, three seriously, by an axe-wielding assiallant. The incident took place on a train operating between...

The Geneva Motor Show 2016

86th Geneva International Motor Show
2016 marks the 86th Geneva International Motor Show. During this prestigious motor show, the Car of the Year is unveiled, and this year, there are...

Bad Aibling fatal train collision

Bad Aibling train collision
Two passenger trains have crashed near Bad Aibling, south east of Munich, with police claiming at least four people have died and many more...

Police Issue Terror Alert for Munich

Munich police issue terror alert
Munich: Bavarian Police have issued a terror alert, warning people to stay away from crowded spots on New Year eve. As the night rang in the New...

Munich jobs fair for engineers

The Association of German Engineers' Recruitment Day
The Association of German Engineers (VDI) is hosting an engineering recruitment fair on the 19th November in Munich.  The day-long event commences at...

Advertise with The Munich Eye
Public Service Advertisements
Shades of Love
Spanish Finca for rent Web Site Optimisation
Newspaper sudoku